RE: Up 7%25 May 2026 13:08
This all smacks of another blunder in our increasingly complex tax system. Policy objective: "We want to encourage investment in UK Stocks and Shares". Action: "Restrict what people can save tax free in a Cash ISA". Unintended consequence: "People hold cash (or cash like instruments) in Stocks and Shares ISAs". Action: "Tax the return on cash in an investments ISA". Unintended consequence: "People invest less wisely, not holding cash when they should".
This kind of tinkering is why our tax code runs to hundreds of pages. I've always thought that allowing the holding of international stocks in an ISA is an anomaly. If we accept that capital gains are taxed, why do we allow investment in overseas companies to benefit from taxpayer cash subsidy? Surely ISAs should be limited to UK listed investments. This would have the benefit that more fund managers and even companies may choose to list in the UK to capture some of that pool of money. If you want to invest in US tech stocks, go ahead. But you'll have to do it in a trading account and pay tax on your gains. Oh, and don't even get me started on Stamp Duty!
Let's use tax incentives to encourage desirable outcomes. Pensions/SIPPS should be left alone... no more restrictions on those please! Keep it simple, not add a whole new set of pages defining what "cash" means in a stocks and shares ISA.