RE: France19 May 2021 12:31
@ 1.butchers.bike
That is a REMARKABLY interesting find, thanks for sharing.
I stand by my initial reaction to this that the issue is simply down to over ordering at the start of the pandemic and then DHSC trying to wiggle out of paying by using their weight and expecting suppliers to bow down to them as they are government backed.
The house broker S P Angel kind of hinted at this position also.
Its pleasing to see that so many are starting to finally get resolved.
We know for a fact that the dispute has nothing to do with product quality a) the £ 3bn framework award included both Novacyt subsidiaries to supply the DHSC, this would not happen if the quality was in question and b) RNS this week confirmed we are supplying the NHS hence reconfirms same.
So, over ordering and what was agreed, now looks highly likely the cause of the dispute.
As I see it based on all the invoices and the declared spends to the year end by DHSC, based on my own calculations, so ignore/ agree as you see fit, there are three possible outcomes here imo: -
Bear: DHSC are right, Novacyt is wrong and a refund of £27m will be granted to DHSC to resolve the dispute deducted from Q4 2020 earnings declared.
Neutral: DHSC and Novacyt reach a mediation, and nothing is further due from DHSC and there are no refunds from Novacyt either. Or some further stock deal is agreed at discount or some other adjustment that has little impact to either party.
Bull: DHSC realise that the contract stands, they must pay the minimum contract order price agreed for the period and Novacyt are then able to invoice £ 23m being the contract shortfall which will add to revenues going forward.
Anyhow we should all know soon enough, and should the matter still drag on to the end of H1, which frankly is not in anyone’s interests DHSC or Novacyt’s then, a provision in the declared accounts will be made confirming the exact position. Either way total clarity.
Meanwhile, imo the bear position has already been completely factored into the Share Price, so I see it as only positive from here. Damage has been done; we are at fire sale share price levels, so its all north from here.
As I say, I remain VERY positive.
GLA
Pork’s