Renegotiate or Walk Away10 Jan 2016 09:53
It is impossible to say whether the dividend will be cut, if the price of oil does not increase in the next year or two and if the demand for oil reduces due to the economy, it is a possibility. Hence the fall in share price, the market is pricing in the risk. What is becoming increasingly certain though is that the tie up with BG is a bad deal. Once upon a time drilling in the Arctic was a good idea, it isn't anymore because the figures don't stack up. The reasons for purchasing BG were right, it will leave Shell in a dominant position in the gas market and gas is the future of energy, but the timing is all wrong. Shell have overvalued BG and miscalculated on oil prices. By spending much of their free cash on BG, this increases the risk that there will not be sufficient funds to maintain dividends. It is also bad management and poor accounting to expend cash reserves purchasing an asset, only to then subsequently have to borrow money to sustain dividends. Shell have said that they intend to offload assets to pay for the deal, but in the current market, those assets will have to be sold at an undervalue, again that's bad management. The downturn in oil prices is proving to be sharper and more prolonged than they anticipated when the offer was made. Had the offer not been made when it was the BG share price would be much lower than it is today. Shell need to renegotiate the deal or walk away. There are plenty of other oil and gas assets out there are present such as Tullow or Premier Oil which represent much better value and there are many companies offloading oil and gas assets at an undervalue which Shell could mop up very cheaply.