RE: Absolute returns, and all that...19 Sep 2019 02:43
Hi James
Like strictly I am almost completely invested in Builders because of Profits, Margins, Cash and Divis. Imho a justifiable Per could be 2 * or more than current levels - and so Sp's. Hence unequalled value.
I don't believe housing is cyclical any more, while recession, Brexit and withdrawal of H2B will have no affect on New House Sales.
Demand for housing depends entirely on Interest rates and mortgage availability.
First point (cyclical nature), when was the last recession? (other than Banking crisis, decreasing Mortgage availability). About 25 years ago? Some cycle! The previous slumps in building caused by Govt increasing Interest rates, which also caused recessions (recession did Not cause the slumps). But Govt no longer controls Interest rates, BofE does.
Builders fortunes depend on the Supply / Demand imbalance. None of the last 3 points, affects this.
Based on a return to Pre Brexit Per's, I calcd bwy 80% uvald, bdev 60%, with psn, rdw and tw somewhere in-between them. This also assumes a return to (undervalued) Pre Brexit levels, hence my 2* + estimate, or 100+ % increase in Sp if we remain in. For the reasons above even if No deal Brexit it does not affect Builders values, but Sp's won't reflect that until the market realises their preconceptions were all wrong (as they see continued massive profits, margins).
Another calc I did was my last 4 years Divis as % age of Total Divi:
2016 10%, 2017 20%, 2018 28%, 2019 42%.
As you can see Brexit has had a massive affect on Builders ?!
It has obviously helped them considerably as Sp's go down increasing Divi % ages. I think this alone proves my point.
BoL