RE: Stuff like this needs an rNs17 Jun 2025 09:48
Whilst there no commercial acumen or structured argument, he might be right but it's really not hard to be right on downward calls in the market today.
So my take is like yours ... ALSA can manage debt post US sale.
So where analysts and profiling is generating this 'short' is on net assets. A significant part of this have been intangible reduction and provision. Historic activity loaded the intangibles and on the most part it's been proven they are not work the value. So ... where is that net asset value heading. The US sale will surely have an intangible knock off on the opposing side of the credit so at £220m at year end, this becomes important and precarious. Everything from new contract limitations and pressure for capital restructuring. The fact is petrofac is a closer and more relevant comparison than CIneworld but then that sums up Firepowers knowledge pool (devoid of any water). It's not really about the run rate of the business but more about the debt pile and how close they get to creditor based issues.
So this is the angle for doom and gloomers and why the 'math' analysis is putting this as a short. However, I personally think it's a close call but ALSA saves this with the trail that have lit on fire at the moment. Their profit and cash generation alone save the company even with the stinkheaps in UK and DE.
That's my take and some background on what the opposing argument could be if someone commercial was making the case.