RE: Hardman - Updated Research3 Mar 2019 12:03
SoupChicken, I think I would tend to agree with you if it were not for two things. 1) COS is currently at cash flow break even or at least should be in the coming months. 2) the imminent approval and launch of Chondromimetic. We know that GP on sales will be between GBP 600 and 700 per pack. In my view in months 12 to 24 after launch they should be able to do at least 5,000 packs (I actually think they can do a lot more but thinking worse case) given the cash flow break even has been reached most of that GBP 3,000,000 will fall to the bottom line. In addition the underlying business will have added an addition GBP 1,000,000 to revenue or 700k to GP. So you are looking at a business with net cash flow of @ GBP 4 million in 24 months time this is vs a market cap of GBP 13 million today. If I was to plug a more optimistic case for Chondromimetic you could be pushing GBP 8,000,000 to GBP 12,000,000 in FCF. The other way I think about it and I accept it may be flawed, is that whey they convert a surgeon I assume they will only use Chondromimetic and no longer use micro fracture. An average surgeon does @ 175 procedures per year and an average procedure uses 1.5 packs. So to get to 5,000 packs per year they only need to convert 20 surgeons. We also know that there are a handful who are ready to use the product from day one.
So in summary I think the real delta between your view and mine comes down to the outlook for Chondromimetic. I am happy to hear an alternative view on Chondromimetic. My view is based on my experience as to how few long term effective treatments there are for Cartilage damage.