RE: City wire article12 Dec 2024 08:21
Allianz warns on Close Brothers’ legal battle
Close Brothers (CBG) could face ‘significant liabilities’ and an extension of the regulatory investigation into its motor finance practices, says Allianz Global Investors’ managers Simon Gergel and Richard Knight.
The pair hold the private bank in their £263m Allianz UK Listed Equity Income fund, where it has been a detractor given its part in the ongoing motor finance commission debacle.
The group was impacted by a high court ruling in a case concerning historic commission payments made to car dealers for selling motor finance packages.
‘The court ruled that these commissions should have been separately disclosed and agreed with the car purchaser. This was a surprise ruling, as it overturned the original court decision, and the policies were compliant with Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) rules at the time,’ said Gergel and Knight.
The two managers said the ruling ‘potentially opens up significant liabilities’ for Close Brothers and other lenders
‘Close Brothers is going to appeal this case to the supreme court, and in the meantime has suspended this finance, while they update procedures,’ they said.
‘There is already an ongoing FCA review into motor finance, which now seems likely to be extended, to take into account any supreme court ruling.’
The shares rose 4.1% to 247.8p on Wednesday, but have fallen 69% over the last 12 months.