RE: ASSESSMENT OF INCREASES TO NPV AND PRICE TARGETS21 May 2025 15:06
Great post @Bramlaby, drowned out by the usual nonsense on here, most of which likely comes from market maker accounts designed to create confusion
I agree that the potential changes to Havieron production should have a substantial impact on any NAV / NPV and resultant broker target prices. I suspect we'll get a much clearer picture on potential impacts once we get on the ASX, the key question being how we plan to integrate the 3-5mtpa Havieron ore with existing Telfer output.
I've not attempted to model any impact on NPV as it's a moving feast with much of it being driven by the gold price and Telfer discoveries. I could see some value in being able to work on sensitivity analysis etc, however it's fairly obvious that the current market cap doesn't account for very much!
The bottom line is that we currently trade at ~3.5x EV/EBITDA using FY26 full year production forecasts and have a world class mine in development whilst owning world class infrastructure + a world class proven producer in Telfer.
Pure play Australian peers trade at a significantly higher multiple per my calculations (no investment advice);
Evolution has an A$17.5b market cap with A$1.6b net debt at the half year and generated A$1b underlying EBITDA in H125, so assume $2.5b for the full year and they trade on a 7.5x multiple
Genesis have an A$4.7b market cap with A$200m net cash at half year, they generated A$154m underlying EBITDA in H125, so assume A$350m for the full year and they trade on a multiple of ~12.5x
Capricorn metals have an A$3.9b market cap with A$300m net cash at half year, they generated A$95m EBITDA in H125, so assume A$250m for the full year and they trade on a multiple of ~14.5x
Northern Star have a A$27.5b market cap with net debt of A$200m at half year, they generated A$1.4b in underlying EBITDA in H1, so assume A$3.5b for the full year and they trade on a multiple of ~8x
There are several other mid cap producers like Ramelius who are merging with Spartan, Westgold that have production issues, however using the above 4 examples I get a blended EV/EBITDA multiple of 10.6x
So a base case price target for me would be 10x EV/EBITDA, which for next year would be ~10*£400m + cash of likely £500m. That is a share price of ~33p.
In a nutshell, I think we should sit above the main ASX mid cap pack but well below an Evolution / Northern Star, so ~A$9b market cap feels about right. No investment advice / DYOR, but to me