RE: Market Cap24 Nov 2020 12:37
Nyuni / Kiiwani versus Ntorya? Do you really think that these are of material interest to ARA ? The ROCE of these is unproven at best, still has a lot of issues to sort out, will require development capital and based on KN1 experience might be more time, effort and money than it is worth. I really do not think that ARA are likely to be making a decisions based upon the "value" now or in the future of Nyuni/Kiliwani. It will probably take just as long to get Kiliwani North into production as it will Ntorya.... The only advantage that Kili has over Ntorya is a "GSA" but one which the TPDC are not honouring as the invoice issues illustrate.
I have no beef at all with the idea of spending money on remediating KN1 and have been advocating for that for an eternity - but it cannot be argued that nothing has moved on this for about three years - why, oh why, do you think that is likely to change anytime soon? The first step in that process is paying or overdue invoices - I cannot see the TPDC rushing to the front of the queue for that, can you? I desperately hope I am wrong as I see it as our short term salvation if so.
And yes HM I have no argument with your suggestion though still need to emphasise that whatever we get from WEN (or anyone else for that matter) today WILL undoubtedly result in a dilution of PI value either immediately (share or asset dilution) or at some future date (share of income) - it is absolutely unavoidable....
As edgar has suggested far better that we dilute our Nyuni/ Kiliwani interests to raise "funding" but for a variety of reasons I do not see that as being particularly attractive to a third party - there is too much risk in it and no guarantee of a compelling ROCE. Different altogether if we manage to successfully remediate KN1 but I am sceptical about that for a variety of historic reasons, all long since aired on this board.
Sorry but I now really must sign off - have arrived at my meeting now.