RE: Dont vote for MA15 Nov 2024 16:40
Alex I'm not saying the Kamanis have been good for shareholders.
My average is low 30s, so I expect to make money. So they haven't been that bad for me.
The reason I invested here was for Debenhams, I've been consistent for many months that it is the future. I can see a strategy evolving with the current BoD.
Debt will be reduced, Debenhams I believe will continue to grow massively and the founder of PLT is back to hopefully turn that around. It seems the UK market position has stabilised. So I can see a future.
With Ashley I can see nothing, precisely because he has said nothing about what his intentions are.
He has a track record of pursuing his own self interest, so I'm not sure why so many seem willing to blindly believe in him.
All of the things you mentioned, such as partnering Debenhams with his retail estate could be done without him becoming CEO, if he behaved in a supportive manner.
So my view for now is quite simple. I can see a strategy evolving under the current BoD. I haven't a clue what the challenger position is.
Ashley has no real online experience, he achieved absolutely nothing with Misguided and has basically screwed Studio shareholders.
If you are comfortable supporting someone on hypotheticals, then good luck. Personally I'd like to see something more concrete.
What I am certain of is that there is no way an Ashley CEO/Kamani chairman relationship will work. So we would have boardroom mayhem, with Umar likely leaving as I don't believe for a second he will work with Ashley
I also remain to be convinced how he can work for the benefit of all Boo shareholders when he owns so much of Frasers and Frasers owns so much of Asos