RE: on the dip20 May 2021 15:07
Seagulls, Ok, but of course its all unknown, all TA is doing is trying to show what move in the SP is more likely.
The criticism of TA being hind sight or past experience, is as valid as valuing any other company. What is the typical success failure rate of exploration companies? What is the current/past cost of helium? what is the historical weather pattern in that part of Tanzania, How long typically does it take to construct a well site.? etc etc
All of the info that you are making value judgements on in your system (which I am not rubbishing), is based on previous info and experience of others in similar situations and environments and trying to transpose them over into the particular unique aspects of this project/company and then make a FUTURE projection.
The only bit that I think is mostly ignored in value investment strategies is that everything that is known about a company is already in the current SP.
The Late Jim Slater wrote a seminal book called "The Zulu Principle" many years ago, where expert knowledge that the PI could research, could in fact give them an edge over professionals who simply did not have the time to do such research. However in this digital age, that edge has been (imo) severely eroded if it exists at all.
So when all this dissection and speculation about seismic reports and pulling apart every word from every report, well that info is already out there, and the SP has reacted accordingly.
If you want to buy now its on the premise that the Drilling will be successful, but we all know the unknowns, Seals, actually finding viable commercial quantities of HE, the Govt Tax on HE that will follow a discovery. All of this may turn out well, but it may not. Its a judgement call based on the info you know at present.
Personally I don't see the difference in the way the methodologies are constructed between FA and TA (You look at the past to see if it can point to a likely future outcome)
The big difference is that TA focuses on the SP and FA on the company and that is a very important distinction between the two.
Its TA that is actually looking at the only thing that maters because it will be the SP that determines the entry and exit price and therefore the success or failure of the transaction for the individual.
Anyway, that's my take. But I have done enough times to know my timing is not "random luck"
Cheers