Coal price should be supply/demand driven not sentiment15 Nov 2021 10:05
Can someone help me understand...
Why would talks of phasing out coal in the future have any effect on coal price today? I understand why it would effect the SP of a coal miner as you would now see a limited timescale for return etc but the actual physical price of coal should not go up and down based on predictions/long term forecasts.
X amount of coal is needed to be burnt tomorrow and Y amount of coal has been mined and is ready to be supplied. That should be the only driver of coal prices. In fact, if anything, the news that coals is to be phased out should strengthen short term prices ("You may not need us in the future so whilst you DO need us now we are going to squeeze every penny"), New coal mines and operations will be less appealing to venture capitalists so supply should stagnate and maybe fall.
My point is that announcing in the future there will be less demand does not alter demand today and if anything supply my reduce faster than demand in the medium term.
In summary - I don't take issue with a coal miner being valued less off the COP announcement that makes sense - there is a finite time period to return on investment but I struggle with the commodity price being effected - This is not logical supply and demand which a commodity whose value is being burnt every day should be.
Appreciate counter views.
Thanks