RE: Consolation prize28 May 2022 11:21
Some already updated analysts numbers... with some comments:
1. They re seeing debt reduction a little bit too negative, thinking that end of 2023 HBR will still have debt, which is highly unlikely
2. They re forecasting revenues to drop by 10% per year, which I think is too negative, given HBR´s ability to replace reserves plus they are (like about all analysts) calculating with lower oil/gas prices than the current one´s
3. What is baked in here (and that´s good) is HBR´s inherited tax losses from Premier Oil, they will be used up end of 2023 with the WT tax, meaning that 2024 HBR will pay substantially more taxes. BUT: of course we all know that in 2024, HBR will be a different company, probably with some major assets outside the UK, so I´d take the predictions for 2024 with some caution.
4. What one can see with these numbers is that: with a PE ratio of under 3 HBR is undervalued. One can also see that the market stays rather negative for the longer term outlook (2024 and further), pricing in a major fall in revenues and earnings. This is where I think the market was and is wrong.
5. The share price will adapt to the fundamentals, but only once several shareholders like GIC and others have sold out. The main reason for the share price not going up with all other oilers last year was former creditors and some old shareholders selling,GIC was responsible for the shareprice only going up to 520 and then going down, selling over 10% of all shares and who knows if there are still other shareholders wanting to sell out. As a matter of fact though, this selling will end one day. But of course such a restructuring of major shareholding takes a lot of time as we saw and see.
So here we go for the numbers:
December 2021 2022 2023 2024
Enterprise Value (EV)2 6 580 6 170 5 426 4 412
P/E ratio 41,3x 3,25x 3,56x 5,86x
Capitalization / Revenue 1,27x 1,02x 1,08x 1,12x
EV / Revenue 1,89x 1,26x 1,18x 0,99x
EV / EBITDA 2,71x 1,70x 1,56x 1,37x
Price to Book 8,87x 2,80x 1,73x 1,57x