RE: Windfall tax11 Jun 2022 18:09
HBR is catastrophically undervalued and funds are selling, why?
=========================================================
I am too invested in HBR and like to give 2 different views to the above very legitimate and pertinent question.
For start the question above is a good question based on a fact, not personal assumptions or even worst, a conspiracy theories.
On conspiracy theories though some time I suppose they can be used as an answer, in absence of proves or certainties...is for anyone choice then to believe them or not.
So some fund are selling.
First view is accepting that HBR is catastrophically undervalued, so why fund sells...
Only logical assumption is that POO will come down badly by end of the year due to recession, (mind you has to be a world recession) and therefore HBR shares are not worth holding, not even if by end 2022, the HBR would have repaid all its debit.
Then there is the question of how much will POO go down, because if it will nevertheless stay above current edging levels, same for gas, with edging disappearing next year, HBR will still make more profits even at lower oil price.
Many factors involved and not easy to predict, possibly not even for a fund management.
Current market correction is creating many good entry opportunities out there, could it be that some funds need to release capital to reinvest in what seen for them a better return.
This doesn't means that HBR is a bad investment.
My second view is that HBR is NOT catastrophically undervalued.
And possibly this is the more close to the truth explanation and would also explain why SOME funds not everyone, is changing investment strategies (good luck to them).
Share price move also if not more on sentiments than fundamentals, if sentiments turn there can be opportunities to invest for the mid/long time frame, but because this kind of investment is based on fundamentals, often is needed for these fundamentals to be realised and materialised, otherwise it would be another short term investment on sentiments.
Sorry the repetitions and possibly simplicity of concept, but often when we are taken by strong convictions and emotions we tend to lose track on the simple facts...(please don't ask why do I know this)
...and so (I think there was a recent post on this board titled HBR v Serica, on valuation)
Sekforde rightly pointed out that due to its current debit still to be repaid (and I would add the stupid edging), HBR valuation by the market is not immediately perceived as very good value, compared to some other peers or other investments .
Indeed I see HBR as fair valued with great potentials if POO stays high and possibly my investment decision is more based on the POO than on HBR, although if POO will stay high in to 2023, I think HBR will bring much higher returns that Serica for example.
Often the truth lays in the middle, but possibly in stead of focusing on why some funds are selling, we should focus on if will POO remain high for 2/3 yer