RE: The Sales6 Dec 2016 14:15
Patchy, I think you have a number of good points there and at least one which misses the mark. On one hand, you’re correct that the AS business was more profitable and therefore it’s a big decision to let it go. However they’ve sold it at a very high multiple, even by sector standards. There’s a lot of change/M&A going on in the sector at present, so they’ve managed to get rid of it at the perfect time, for a cracking price. I’d say UHS has overpaid significantly for it actually, but as a CMBN shareholder I can hardly complain!
That said, the business is now going to be significantly smaller, for sure. Being debt free with a mostly-freehold property portfolio goes a long, long way in this sector so they’re definitely in a good spot. If some of the old habits of the BOD come back – taking on way more debt, paying over the odds to acquire competitors etc. – then I’ll start to reduce my holding and take my profits. I’ll be watching closely from here and won’t be afraid to sell if I think they’re wasting the good position which they currently find themselves in.
I don’t agree with your reading of ‘the dividend’ however, as it isn’t a proper dividend at all. This is some of the proceeds of the AS business sale being passed back to shareholders. We’ll have to wait and see what happens with the ‘proper’ dividends when they resume next year. I’d probably stay out of CMBN if I were you to be honest, as 100% of your posts on LSE to date have been expressing some level of scepticism towards this share – there’s obviously something there which you’re fundamentally not comfortable with.