IJWT9 Sep 2018 10:52
"It is a bad deal. Except in the most severe of economic downturns they are giving up a quarter of the oil for $180m. With expenditure of around $100m other.options would have been available. Additionally, the absence of meaningful ratchets (commonplace in commercial transactions) it is very skewed to the benefit of Spirit."
I can understand your view, and on a purely finance based analysis you make sense. Three things, tho, make me rate it a good deal.
Firstly, there is no saying where PoO goes over the next few years, and this gets Linwick moving much quicker than HUR could have done. HUR still retain upside in the 50% stake they keep..
Secondly, it will sharpen the minds of others, majors included, regarding Lancaster and/or Halifax, for which much better terms should be obtained.
Thirdly, we must remember these fields do not belong to HUR, they are licensed to us by HM Govt ; the OGA may have had a hand here, both in pushing HUR to accelerate things and in pushing the WOSP operators to make room for us.
I too am a little surprised at the absence of ratchets ; I can only assume this was the best deal available. And by doing it, HUR may have broken the logjam on the "buyers' strike" referred to by dspp, particularly by the WOSP deal above.
all imho, of course.