RE: Comp3 Apr 2017 16:21
Maybe I’m in cloud cuckoo land, but all these t/o sp predictions look very pessimistic guys. In fact I’m proud to be topping the competition list at 125pps!
Up until the 14/11/16 RNS the SP had been stable for months around 80p. Even then the finncap target of 113p looked unchallenging, and would have equated to a PE ratio of about 13. The industry peer group was much higher, eg Rotork on 17, with little obvious reason for HAYT to be lagging behind.
Little has actually changed since then. It seems to be perceived (rather than real) concerns causing the current SP weakness. The business concerns seem to stem primarily from an accounting policy point, ie the orders thought to have been bookable to H2 2017, weren’t. So yes 2017 results are affected but it’s only a timing point. It seems to have become an issue because HAYT and RBS between them relaxed the financial covenants prematurely, and agreed overoptimistic debt repayment schedules. In trying to unpick that, it’s degenerated into a bit of a chimps tea party.
But the orders are still there, and have just “shifted to the right”, and are flowing nicely now.
Long term funding is connected and taking an age to sort out, but the most likely outcome is that it’ll be sorted this month, by revised debt facilities (ie term loans RCFs and overdraft). I say that because after a few short term extensions, the 6 weeks period HAYT and RBS gave themselves on the 16 March, coupled with putting back the financial covenants measurement, has the air of RBS and HAYT both believing it’s a long enough timeframe to sort long term financing once and for all.
These are certainly challenging times, but the dividend is still there, the people and business and partnerships are still there, the re-fitted state-of-the-art premises are still there, the pipeline and orders are still there. The “bad news” for YE 2017 should all now be out in the open now. Speculation about wider financial problems and re-capitalisation through rights issues etc looks premature and without foundation. They’re the sorts of conclusions you might reach if you’re worrying and fearful about delays and think this means more bad news to come, but what actual evidence is there for that? HAYT and RBS between them have certainly made a dogs dinner of orders timing predictions and financing since November, but have given plausible reasons and timeframes now to sort it all out. I expect we’ll be sorted out and should be back up towards 80pps again by end April, assuming the AVG move comes to nothing.
If there’s a t/o, then there’s no way HAYT should be valued less than 125pps if there’s no more specific bad news to emerge.
All IMHO and WTFDIK etc