RE: Covid 1910 Sep 2020 13:05
Hi Nige_W
some people might question your coming to the Sage board to promote HBs at a time when you were actively selling them, you can see how that looks, and they might even be skeptical at your belated mention of GGP, but I think we should give you the benefit of the doubt and thank you for making full disclosure, if a little late.
If HBs are now well prepared for a slump, presumably because they are already so low, that's slightly different from seeing value in them. It's interesting that you do actually still disapprove of the Sage buy back program, and it seems that however low the price goes as a result of COVID-19 (they were around £6 when this thread started), you would still see it as too expensive and a bad way of using resources. Despite this, you see no specific reason for that high rating to change, which seems contradictory. If the share price is not likely to be derated lower in the future, then how can price be an objection to the value of the buy back program? If earnings increase, today's price might be seen as cheap with hindsight, and more earnings spread over the resulting fewer shares would lower the PER. In such a scenario the price is likely to go up again, at which point you would be put off by the still high PER. You would probably never invest.
I think we can agree that comparisons over PER are interesting, but can only be taken so far. Good luck with GGP, they've had a golden year so far!