RE: TFG: The Enigma wrapped up in a mystery12 Feb 2022 09:23
https://citywire.com/investment-trust-insider/news/trust-watch-big-new-bargains-as-markets-get-in-a-muddle/a2378673?ref=investment-trust-insider-comment-analysis-list#i=2
Tetragon’s titanic discount
For a change, we start with the week’s big risers. Tetragon Financial (TFG), although not the biggest gainer in our table, is the standout performer with the dormant shares in the alternative investments group jumping to life with a 9.5% leap by Thursday’s close.
That left it in fifth place in our list of investment company fliers, behind the volatile cent or penny stock that is DP Aircraft (DPA), and a broad bevy of private equity funds. Most notable of these is Seraphim Space (SSIT), which rallied 19% after its thumping in the January selloff to leave its shares standing on a 9% premium over NAV, but still down nearly 10% so far this year.
For seasoned watchers of Tetragon, a $2.9bn (£2.1bn) hedge fund with stakes in a range of fund managers, a share price rally in early February is almost a yearly event. That’s because at the end of January it publishes its NAV for 31 December, which includes an annual revaluation of the private equity stakes in its TFG Asset Management business. These jumped 35% to $1.25bn, pushing asset value up 11.6% in December and leaving the portfolio with a total underlying gain of 14.1% for 2021.
Forthcoming annual results will reveal which companies drove this performance, although from earlier statements it looks to be infrastructure fund manager Equitix. In the meantime, investors can only wonder when Tetragon’s chronically wide discount, now stretching to 68% with a market value of just £664m, will ever narrow?
Stifel analyst Iain Scouller lives in hope and believes following Monday’s statement the shares are worth tucking away in the hope something will be done – such as a flotation of the asset management business – to provide a catalyst for a gigantic rerating of the share price.
‘A wide discount has persisted for a long time and is not in itself a reason to buy the shares. However, we assume that at some point common sense will prevail and the board and management will come up with a proposition such as a restructuring to both recognise and realise value for shareholders,’ Scouller said.
Until then, don’t expect fireworks. Despite a 57% investment gain in the past five years, the shares have fallen 10%, illustrating how far the company has fallen out of favour.