RE: THS vs SLP vs JLP5 Dec 2020 20:46
Hi Scoobydoo!
All are good investments, IMO, and all offer strong exposure to the booming rhodium price as they are processing UG2 ore, which is particularly rich in rhodium. This is how I'd summarise them:
THS is a well-run PGM / chrome open pit miner with long life of mine, good growth potential, and excellent fundamentals. Also, the stock has not really rerated yet even though the business is going really well. So it wins out on potential price growth.
SLP produces PGMs from tailings and run of mine material from chrome miner Samancor. Well-run, debt-free cash-rich, excellent fundamentals and stock (though it has risen) is still cheap. If you want to pick holes in the case for SLP you'd note that the life of mine is quite short (8 years or so), that they are very much dependent on Samancor, and that they haven't yet outlined a convincing growth strategy.
JLP is more of a mixed bag. It produces chrome and PGMs from ore / tailings in SA, and also it has an ambitious plan to produce copper from tailings in Zambia. Buying JLP shares you are more buying the hope of growth than the reality of big profits today. Risks are higher here: execution and political risk in Zambia, corporate governance risk (Chairman is Colin Bird!), and risks relating to their chrome ore suppliers in SA.
Full disclosure: I own THS and SLP shares.