RE: Tjate - Northern Shark13 Dec 2020 14:43
I'm sorry, Mikie, I wasn't clear in my post.
I think - on a good day - JLP might get $50m to $100m for their 64% share of Tjate. Maybe nearer $50m. That would be a truly great result for JLP, who could invest the unexpected windfall in new rapid turnaround high return metal tailings projects.
These undeveloped PGM assets are simply not worth the money that you and other EUA investors seem to think they are. Look at Tharisa, they have a mega asset in Karo, which the market doesn't value at all.
The current PGM boom has an expiry date, which is essentially the date when diesel and gasoline engined vehicles start to be replaced by electric ones, turning what is now a very tight market for PGMs into a looser one. Separately, the economics of rhodium (simply irreplaceable in cats) are stronger than the economics of palladium, as cheaper platinum can be used in palladium's place, with certain limitations (sintering). This substitution is apparently already occurring.
In short, there is a not a huge amount of economic sense in buying an undeveloped PGM resource and spending a huge amount of Capex on it to turn it into a mine by, say, 2025; as by then PGM prices may well have fallen back. (There should be an asterisk here, as widespread adoption of green hydrogen technology would change that. But, note, hydrogen technology mostly uses platinum-iridium-ruthenium catalysts, rather than palladium-rhodium ones.)
I don't know what game Blackrock are playing, but it is probably not the one you think it is. I'm still confident that EUA is wildly overvalued. There is no way on earth that a small Russian palladium dominant resource plus a larger "exploration target" in the Russian far north is worth the kind of money EUA investors think it is.
If only it were so! It would imply JLP, SLP, and THS were ten or twenty times undervalued by the market. All are excellent companies, with good prospects, and IMO will increase in value. But, no, they won't ten bag in a day!