RE: Stick or Twist, That is the question ?9 Apr 2026 15:45
This is a fun discussion.
For savvy investors this is a moving target. You look at what it's worth now compared to when you bought it, and whether the upside has significantly changed.
I first got in at 6p, then a lot more at 9p (old shares), more at 12p. By then, I had a final target of £1 ( £20 in today's shares).
It's not really the right approach but my conservatism means I really value being on a free carry. I shouldn't. I should compare the price today to where I think it is going. Silly of me, but if I can sell 1/3 or fewer and be on a free carry, I will do it, then hold the rest. It isn't optimal investing philosophy but it soothes my caution. If I can get to a free carry with fortunate trading without reducing my core holding, all the better. That typically only happens with a volatile share and sometimes some luck.
I do monitor my price target and move it if there are major events. Acquiring Telfer certainly moved my target. My ultimate target is now £40. If we hit that, I'm entirely out (unless there are more target-moving events, of course). A resource upgrade isn't a target mover. Finding another Hav, near enough to have infrastructure synergy, would be.
I do laddered profit-taking. I'll reduce my current position at £10 by 5%, the same at 15, 20, and 25. At £30, and £35, I'll sell 10%. Those points could change if there are target changing events, too.
All of that would change if I had a mortgage or wanted to spend on something important to me, or if family or a good friend could use funds for a good purpose. The point is not to maximise investments, the point is to maximise life. If there were good reason to access some of these funds, I'd sell now. There could be a point where I start to liquidate / give it away to reduce IHT impact, but I don't have anyone who needs it now and I'm not that old yet.
It's all very personal. What's your risk tolerance? What would you use it for if it weren't invested? Do you want to look for another investment? Do you enjoy making a bet on high risk / high reward opportunities or do you like a significantly derisked miner? How are things with your family? Anyone you would like to help? What's your IHT situation and does it matter to your family? These are different for everyone and they all go into the "right" decision. There usually are decisions that are "right" or "wrong" and few people think it through fully taking all the factors into account. But "right" for one person is "wrong" for another, and who cares if someone else decides differently from me? I just hope everyone thinks it through and does what is right for their circumstances / outlook.