RE: Chinook vs Cascadura - more to come?1 Aug 2021 10:21
As an investor, dividends means the company decides when you'll pay taxes. With share buybacks it's up to you to sell and be taxed. As a foreign investor you might also have trouble with withheld dividend tax and getting that refunded. At the bare minimum the company (IMO) should cover all warrants through buybacks, or retail investors will be diluted.
Of course if the company is trading at a P/E >20 with no growth expected, share buybacks makes little sense. In a company at a P/E of 1 dvidend doesn't make sense. (Imagine TXP doing full share buyback and you were the only investor not to sell AND the share price was unaffected - then you would own TXP 100% in 5 years time maybe). So of course share price increases as shares are bought back since 1 share means a larger ownership.
So for tax reasons i prefer share buyback, at least to the point where a high forward P/E makes the company "expensive".