RE: Seasoned thoughts?15 May 2025 16:21
On your risks though:
Financing: 90% (syndicate in place, financing package largely agreed). You're still saying that there is a 1 in 10 chance of this not happening. I would say that at this stage it's more like 1 in 20 max, so I would be more like 95%
Regulatory: 70% (permits granted, but Ethiopia remains unpredictable). I think that the fact that this is Ethiopia works in our favour. If this was the UK you'd have a hundred different government departments and environmentalist groups to satisfy. In Ethiopia if the government want something done, then that's what's happening. Again I'd say that this is 1 in 20 at a push, so 95%
Operational build: 60% (project fully designed and engineered, execution risk remains). This is a bigger risk, but at 60% that is nearly 50:50. There's a risk that some kind of ground condition could occur that would make it more expensive, or perhaps prohibit the under-ground mine, but for an open-pit mine it is pretty low. I think that 60% is far too low. Maybe 10%-15% of it having an impact, but more like 1%-2% of it being critical. For this exercise we could call it 90%
Company governance: 70% (past delays but strong recent delivery and strategy). This is prerogative, but I don't buy into the narrative that there have been past delays - this is how long it takes to launch an multi-billion pound mine, and I think a lot of LTH had unrealistic expectations when they got involved. The fact that we retain 85% equity is astonishing and I actually think that there is no reason to consider this a risk. We also have Lycopodium on board who will effectively be running things anyway.
Geopolitical: 70% (Ethiopia improving but still carries risk premium). Similar risk to Egypt, etc. Not perfect, but I also think that it's a bit much to consider it to be 30% likely (nearly 1 in 3) that there will be an issue to derail TK. We've already had wars, kidnaps, and covid and we're not derailed yet! I'd say more like 85% personally.
Even ignoring concurrency (ie geo-political, would potentially impact finance or regulatory, etc), then it's more like :
95% x 95% x 90% x 85% = 70%
I work the risk out differently, but 70% is in the right ball-park, at this stage imo. Once finance is closed out obviously that risk falls awa, and when we're started Major Works, then regulatory mostly falls away, etc, etc.