For the hard of thinking (like me)...9 Dec 2020 11:18
There was a lot contained in last week's Araguaia Operational Update RNS and it needed a bit of mulling over. In the interests of openness this is by far my biggest holding so it is always under consideration despite the Warren Buffet advice of find a good company, but in and then do nothing!
Basically I have been wondering what next for the share price and how this will play out over the next few months and then few years.
Key points in the update but not said directly -
- Equity dilution will be diminished and is underpinned now by a cornerstone investor. ECAs, Brazilian Banks, offtake agreements.
- No cost inflation despite currency shifts and pandemic effects
- Long term offtakeS are being negotiated. Multiple long term agreements guarantee the income stream, that would add a lot of value.
- Power, permits, team, ESG are all in place to start build. The mine is being built, this is not the set of actions for divestment.
- Nickel base case now $2000 higher than the original FS value of $14000. I don't think it would be unreasonable to work the economics now on $20,000 a ton.
So what will happen to the share price. Before last week it had been very quiet for quite a long time. The share price was drifting, some rainbow chasers lost interest, no new institutional investors coming on board, not a lot happening against a market backdrop of wildly veering prices of even some bluechips. Given the lack of news flow I think the price held up surprisingly well.
If we go into another quiet period it is tempting to think the share price may drift again, but I think perhaps not. There is enough in the announcement to suggest where the longer term value is going. Those of us that got in early enough might be looking at our profits and be tempted to move elsewhere in the quiet period. I'm not but I am sure other PIs have. What we may see is a crew change from early speculators to early investors. As some speculators leave, people looking at a lower risk return may be entering. That's supporting the price now, but may cause it to rise slowly as people digest the news.
So why would early investors enter? Simply because a share price now of in the 6s will in two years time translate to 30p+ as we enter production. If Vermelho is advanced in that period (2 years from PFS) that could add another 40p to the price. Happy to show workings if needed, but even if I am 25% out then it is still a fantastic investment.
This has gone from being a speculation two years ago to being a solid investment now. There are very low risks now with fully permitted assets underpinning the share price, whilst an upside minimum of 5x and possibly 10x plus over two years should attract risk averse growth investors.
In short - this is one of the best low risk investments on the market. I think we will see a drift up as that is more widely recognised, with the occasional mini surge on step change news flow