RE: SP down6 Feb 2025 17:55
Dawson_64 - I agree it does seem puzzling, especially after January's TU which I felt was generally pretty reassuring.
A few possible explanations spring to mind:
1) The TU implied much of the (significant) pledge book growth came in relatively late LY. If so, the main benefit, profits-wise, may only be felt in the current FY.
Since UK markets seem less forward-looking than usual at the moment, they attach less value to future earnings (however certain) than current ones.
2) HAT won't escape the persistent gloomy UK retail & economic backdrop. Personally, I think if there are worries on that front, they're largely misplaced. April's NI increase will undoubtedly add to costs (TU implied to the tune of approx. £2m). However the company said it was exploring options to offset this - at least in part. And at times when inflation's ticking up & money's short for a lot of households, there are far worse industries to be in than pawnbroking.
3) Lack of recent share buying by Executive Directors. Personally, this IS a major concern of mine and I made it very clear at last year's results webinar. Their answer was a mixture of waffle and "watch this space" kind of language. Well, I have been watching this space & nothing's changed. So I'll be raising it very forcefully again at this year's webinar.
If Executive Directors feel the current lowly multiple undervalues the company they're running, they should put their money where their mouth is. The amount they earn, most of them must have at least a bit of dosh they could invest. And if they don't feel it's undervalued, perhaps they should come clean (yes I know it's a trifle unlikely they'd let on. But it would be jolly nice of them to let us know!)
4) Many AIM & UK small cap shares are struggling currently, with investors perhaps preferring the perceived (though not always real) safety of blue chips &/or US & global funds.
5) "The market" has simply got it wrong. It wouldn't be the first time with HAT. I've traded this share on several occasions over the years I've held it. Historically, it's often gyrated between periods of over-exuberance & unfounded gloom. My gut feel right now is we're more in the latter camp. In which case an upwards re-rate might be on the cards within the next 12 months. But as I often say with this share, I could be wrong.......