Just to explain myself further13 Dec 2013 12:16
The London insurance market is incredibly durable and strong. However the conditions in which we operate have worsened drammatically in recent years.
Before the recession insurers could be profitable even when their combined loss ratios were above 100% due to high investment returns. But now, with very low interest rates, insurers have been forced to focus on making the underwriting profitable and keep their combined loss ratios below 100% at all costs. Yet - at the same time - there's huge downward pressure on rates and so this has proven to be very difficult.
On top of all of that reinsurance rates are historically low which has meant there are too many market participants all fighting for market share etc which has meant rates cannot increase. Historically, when this has happened, there'll eventually be a huge catastrophe loss that hit some insurers so hard they're forced to withdraw from the market and rates harden. However, with reinsurance rates so low, that hasn't happened, the very high level of competition has remained and rates have stayed low and the forces against insurer's making good profits have remained.
So, when I see QBE and RSA having trouble, I sincerely hope they'll raise rates because they're the sort of respected leading brands who could raise rates without losing much market share and then others would follow. Although, the fear of losing market share, could prevent them from doing so. We'll haveto wait and see...