RE: The choices facing Ariana15 Dec 2019 21:13
Hi Van
As you may expect I don't really agree with some of your points. I'll address them individually
1, The argument you put forward is essentially logical if you assume that a MC of c. £23m truly fully valued Ariana Mk1. In fact yes, then it would then be a cracking deal. But since we have both been on record for several months saying that on fundamentals (not least of which was the imminent flood of cash from a 51% interest in W.Turkey operations) AAU was 2,3,4... times undervalued than the argument doesn't really hold water. And the BOD are on record as saying themselves that the MC very significantly undervalued the company, and you do normally put faith in their judgement
2. What monetarisation? A small special dividend which Dr S has said will be a proportion of the $5m received for 17% of Salinbas? Given the unchanged SP punters could monetise similarly by selling a few shares - AAU Mk1 was over 2.40p in July if you remember.
3. Fair point, provided you think the growth percentage will exceed the proportion of assets given away.
4. Again fair point
Yes more results due. At one time this old saddo would have been excited by that prospect. I ought to get out more I know. Now I think ok, but since we will only have a 23.5% interest in future then I'm in no hurry to read it. I'm not being facetious, this company no longer excites me because of the proposed asset & control giveaway.
I do have faith in the BOD leading Ariana Mk1. Not so sure now they are playing with big fish who have sharp teeth. Essentially Dr S is a fantastic geologist. I have met and respect him. Not sure his heart is as CEO if that means handing over the geology to others. So the company swings back with this deal towards a purer exploration agenda, but seems to be at the price of giving away productive and very profitable W.Turkey assets at a knock down price where no help from a new partner is even needed. The AAU/Proccea JV should remain as is imo. Exploration focus is not the company profile I want. The only thing I can think of to challenge my view on this deal is that MDV seems supportive. He, as we know, is a large (maybe the largest private) shareholder. That almost alone makes me question my current judgement, I have met and respect him too.
Finally, I think Joe has made the point well but I reinforce that I am not to blame for the SP being c.2.20p to anything like the extent you imply. You flatter my superhuman powers! I have sold around 1/2% of the company equity. That is not enough to explain the drop, not only are others obviously selling large(r)) amounts but the SP drop also highlights that punters aren't buying. If this deal was that bloody marvellous then others would be mopping up mine and other sellers shares as soon as they hit the market.