RE: Buy backs21 Jan 2025 06:14
Some excellent points have been raised here, particularly regarding the share count, valuation, and buyback impact. I agree that while the recent buyback is a step in the right direction, it’s not enough to make a significant dent in the overall share count. If we take the 2.848 billion additional shares post-Covid and compare it to the 91.86 million shares likely to be repurchased from the €350m buyback, we’d need around 30 similar buybacks to return to pre-Covid share levels. Given the current share price (€3.81 in Spain), this highlights how costly such an exercise would be.
It’s worth noting that the capital raising in 2020 was essential for the company’s survival during the pandemic, but it did dilute existing shareholders significantly. With the share count now at 4.84 billion compared to 1.992 billion pre-Covid, it’s clear why some struggle to see how a £4-£4.50 share price is achievable when there are more than double the shares in issue.
However, there are positive factors to consider. The company has undergone significant restructuring since 2019, becoming leaner, more efficient, and better focused. With travel demand booming, a record number of passengers, and strong operating margins, 2025 could shape up to be more profitable than 2019. This, combined with a P/E ratio of around 7 (which isn’t excessive), suggests there’s room for further growth in the share price, especially if buybacks continue and dividends return. A fair valuation at £4 doesn’t seem overly optimistic in this context.
That said, the buyback’s limited impact on the share price thus far raises questions about whether market sentiment fully reflects these operational improvements. While some competitors, like Ryanair, face issues with aircraft maintenance and availability, IAG seems to be capitalising on its scale and flexibility, which is an advantage.
Ultimately, I think it’s wise to wait for the full-year results next month before making any major decisions. If they deliver as expected, we could see a further uplift in the share price. DYOR, of course, but I remain cautiously optimistic about IAG’s prospects for 2025 and beyond.