RE: G v OP28 Apr 2020 20:45
G reached it's first high before the DOW was awake, Jack, but your point remains valid - markets (FTSE & DOW) were generally 'up' and the indices are a measure of that. However, any positivity regarding oil and related industries at the moment seems to be misplaced as far as I'm concerned - hence my question about where the enthusiasm was coming from. Much as I welcome the way G has held it together by comparison with the majors (RDS and Chevron) I'm not sure it is justified in the current climate. It doesn't have the benefit of size and diversity of interests and revenue streams. The big guys should, for example, be able to turn OP volatility to good use - especially with their access to trade, storage and shipping - but G has none of these advantages and also has its well rehearsed geopolitical risks. I'm also unconvinced by WTI today - near term futures seem way overpriced given the extreme contango curve. I also suspect that oil may never recover to pre-COVID-19 levels of demand and that the path to even an 80% level of recovery will be slow and tough. In my view, G's resilience will certainly be tested, so any upticks in sp much above 100 - and certainly above 120 - strike me as froth, and I'll happily grab a profit from them if they seem to be unsupported by some underlying rationale. ATB