RE: Eskom Battery Storage Program5 Mar 2019 11:25
(2 of 2)
Then of course we have this gem of a line ;
“Vertical integration in the battery storage value chain (mining, manufacturing, operation) feasible in South Africa”
It is important to understand that SA has in theory the capabilities to set up both lithium-ion and zinc based battery value chains. Nobody has more Mangenese in the world than SA and President Ramaphosa just opened a very large zinc mine in the Northern Cape. SA has also invested in studies to understand the extent to which a lithium-ion battery value chain could commence in SA.
However, I can find no evidence of any company that is capable of achieving this, that is ready to participate in this particular BESS project. That said the likes of Fluence, which is the love child of Siemens and AES must fancy their chances and would likely be able to sell the idea of being able to bring their battery operations to SA if the work was there for them. Siemens have a strong footprint in SA already.
This is just an example of the competition out there. This project is a game chnager for any company that is successful, thus I expect the competition to be strong.
However, I keep coming back to that same thought. How is the Minister of Energy and now Eskom able to say with such confidence that a vertically integrated battery industry value chain that includes mining, beneficiation, manufacture and operation, can be set up in SA, if they haven’t had guidance on it from those that would achieve it. Are the likes of Siemens really demonstrating that in the background. If they were, wouldn’t the IDC be partnering with them as they are with BE? They appear very keen to share the benefits of a VRFB led industry so why not a lithium-ion one?
There is no evidence from any of the IDC Annual Reports that this is the case right now.
Plus we have to remember that all those graphs out there pointing to lithium-ion being the most cost competitive has absolutely nothing to do with SA. When vanadium is able to play out in its own backyard through a fully integrated value chain, lithium in my view cannot be observed in the same light.
All of this is what we already know and what has made it into the public light.
Now imagine the sort of numbers and strategies that BE is banding about to its partner the IDC, that politically, regulatory and financially connected entity.
Like I say the competition should be strong and the list very long, but it is in my view looking very good for BE/BMN with success now mapping a big future for both entities.