RE: Perry Stalsis10 Jul 2018 08:59
Hi Perry!
No, I don't have any problems with your post, and I don't think many others will. It's reasoned and civil.
FWIW, I agree (at least, in part) with some of your points, and I disagree strongly with some others.
A few notes:
a. First up, I agree that Mali offers HUM more interesting opportunities than Liberia, and that company communications have been poor of late, particularly as regards the security incident. I would love to know what effect Beaufort's demise has had on the share price over the last few months, but I'll guess we'll never know that.
b. HUM didn't sell any shares to a selected buyer at a discount, as you state. I assume that you are referring to the bloc sale of shares by La Petite Mine a few months ago here. Yes, HUM may have played a role in finding a buyer for those shares, but that's all. The price would have been negotiated by the two parties, and anybody selling off a huge bloc of shares must expect to be bargained down; that's how markets work.
c. I think you're being unfair to HUM about Dugbe in Liberia. As far as I can see, the intent is not to spend a lot more money on Dugbe; rather it is to conclude the MDA, and to find a joint venture partner who will put up the capital required to develop the mine. I actually feel that HUM have been right to keep quiet about this until everything is signed and sealed - these things are sensitive. Some of the Liberian press allegations are patently ridiculous (such as a Liberian Senator owning 10% of HUM, or Dugbe having 14 trillion ounces of gold). It doesn't bother me that the company hasn't responded to them. As far as I can tell, Liberians don't take their own newspapers very seriously, either.
d. I assume that the potential JV partner for Dugbe will turn out to be Endeavour. There's a lot of circumstantial evidence for this. I also wouldn't be surprised if their name popped up off the shareholders' register in the near future, because I think somebody has been building a strategic stake in HUM behind the scenes. Will this lead to a full takeover in due course? Possibly. And, if so, will Dan Betts get a seat on the Endeavour board? Again, possibly. But, remember, if a takeover does happen, we shareholders will receive a substantial premium on today's share price.
e. Finally, I'm happy to hold shares in a company with such strong fundamentals. And, yes, management might be young and "inexperienced" - but they did deliver a gold mine on time and on budget, and also they did complete its ramp up on schedule. Very few mining executives can boast of that achievement - I believe that on average new gold mines come in 3 months late and 20% over budget. So, for me, HUM remains a strong buy.