Article part 123 Jul 2020 13:20
SolGold boss lashes Newcrest's 'dog in the manger' act
Jul 23, 2020 – 4.47pm
SolGold managing director Nick Mather says Newcrest Mining's decision to remove its board representative is a "dog in the manger act" and has signalled that he will resist a campaign to remove him from the helm of the hotly contested copper and gold explorer. Mr Mather angered his two biggest shareholders, BHP and Newcrest, when he opted to fund the development of SolGold's Cascabel project in Ecuador through high-cost debt rather than equity. BHP and Newcrest are not happy with Nick Mather's management of SolGold. SolGold's $US15 million ($20.97 million) loan from Franco Nevada carries interest rates of 12 per cent and was labelled value-destructive by SolGold's fourth-biggest shareholder, Cornerstone Capital Resources, which is now calling for a spill of the SolGold board over concerns about Mr Mather's management. Franco may lend SolGold a further $US100 million if it can travel to Ecuador to conduct due diligence at the Cascabel site, but the loan remains in limbo as pandemic lockdowns have prevented Franco from visiting the site to date. Asked why he preferred the loan to an equity raising, Mr Mather said he wanted to avoid a situation where BHP and Newcrest's financial firepower enabled them to dilute small shareholders and gradually creep towards control of SolGold. ''One of the valuable themes for small shareholders is a takeover premium and if you lose that, then you have not served your shareholders in the best manner,'' he said. "The board has got to look after the interests of all shareholders, not just a few of them.'' Mr Mather said the Franco deal also gave Cascabel a higher implied valuation than SolGold's current market capitalisation. Newcrest and BHP collectively own close to 27 per cent of SolGold and have long been viewed as likely acquirers of the explorer. But an increasingly frustrated Newcrest removed its representative, technical expert Craig Jones, from the SolGold board in June out of concern for the way the company was being managed, and Mr Mather said that decision would not help SolGold achieve its potential. ''Taking their mining guy off our board is a sort of dog in the manger act by Newcrest,'' he said in a reference to a Greek fable about spitefully denying things to those who need them. "Craig Jones is a block cave mining expert. If you are intending to help look after the future of the company, why would you take your block cave mining expert off the board?" The removal of Newcrest's board representative has come four months before BHP is unshackled from a swathe of standstill clauses that prevent it from exercising its muscle within SolGold, and as SolGold is mired in a messy stoush with Cornerstone.