Read through Muddy waters report once again and NMC's rebuttal5 Feb 2020 18:38
I have gone through the Muddy waters report once again and the rebuttal from NMC. My views:
Since the report has been submitted - The price has reduced from £25 to £9.7 today, a staggering 61.5%
Even if all claims made by Muddy waters are right, i do not think the share price warrants such a big drop i suspect that some might be true, i dont think any company for that matter anywhere in the world will come clean if an independent committee does an audit - there will surely be some gaps
Current PE is 9.85, based on last year 2018 financials, other companies in the same segment in the same industry currently at 22 times (e.g. Mediclinic trades at 22 X PE)
Several analysts are considering NMC shares as deeply undervalued (JP Morgan with target price 3,360 GBP, Barclays with target price 4,275GBP, Krupa Global investments think fair value is £20)
I dont think the company is going bankrupt, just based on those allegations
Company has confirmed that they will meet the guidance for the last year as mentioned previously
With revenues increasing, expansion plans intact, debt reducing, profits increasing think the business is doing well IMO.
Based on the facts it appears undervalued and with time will correct - ignore daily fluctuations