RE: Buyout13 Jun 2025 10:31
MF2017 - I agree with a lot of what you say. And when I give a NAV / NPV Valuation I always make an allowance for sp disparity from inherent value. You are completely correct though, that sentiment trumps calculatable value, and the market can be consistently "wrong" for years. Being able to prove that KEFI is worth £xxxm is irrelevant if the market doesn't agree. Buyers on AIM don't buy based on whether a company is under-valued or not, they buy based on whether the sp is likely to go higher or lower in the next 3-6 months.
I still believe though, that over the long-term the sp has to correct to corelate with actual value and profitability. Even if that takes another couple of years until KEFI starts paying dividends. The thing about KEFI is that the disparity is so HUGE between actual value and the sp, is that it doesn't even have to correct.... just come a bit closer to a correction.
With $3,400/oz gold price, and conservatively assuming 1.9moz, 30% risk (15% for time, 15% for jurisdiction, etc), gives over 12p NPV. Plenty on here would be happy with only 1.2p, so the market can still be completely and ludicrously under-valued, and KEFI still be a massive multi-bagger.
If the theory is that the market is currently valuing the likelihood of Harry getting this over the line, then in theory they are unconsciously applying a 95.5% discount for that risk. I think that at this stage, even the most pessimistic would agree that the risk is much less than 50:50, but the market is valuing KEFI as only having a 4.5% chance of Tulu Kapi happening (also completely disregarding the SA assets!).
Because of how devoid of reason or rational the sp currently is, I find it next to impossible to predict what the sp will be on sign-off. I see lots of people saying 1.5p-2p, so I get the feeling that this is maybe the prevailing sentiment, but then I also understand that this is based on human psyche, and that will completely change when the excitement and fomo of a rocketing sp kicks in. There will be a raft of excited new shareholders buying in a 1.5p, with a different mentality where they fully expect to see 5p, and then a raft of buyers at 5p who can calculate 12p-15p as fair value and fully expect another GGP.
The sentiment of it all is just too hard to predict. In my opinion the time when the sp is most likely to reflect profitability (which is what I look for), will be when dividends are paid. At that time profitability will drive the dividend, and the dividend will drive the sp.