RE: government iniative25 Apr 2020 19:50
Comparing the commercial potential, and therefore market caps of ODX to NCYT is literally apples vs pears.
My view as as follows; Mologic are the test provider, own the IP and therefore control the economics of production and set the price per test. They will receive the cash from the buyer (e.g the government) say it sells for £5 per test for arguments sake. They will pay ODX a % per test produced, let’s be generous and assume this is 20%. So ODX earn £1 per test on a gross basis.
However, NCYT own their test IP and so dictate the economics of production & set the sales price. They will pay their manufacturers (Cytiva / Yourgene etc) a % of the selling price per test, and retain the margin as their gross profit. If NCYT sells a test for £5 and pays a 20% cut, Yourgene get £1 and NCYT £4.
So based on the above example, ODX would need to sell a minimum of 4 x the number of tests to make the same revenue as NCYT. In all likelihood this multiple will be higher as ODX will have manufacturing overheads to cover & the NCYT sales price is more than £5.
NCYT had sold £17.9m of tests to the end of March, prior to scaling up to 4m (and soon to be 8m) tests per month. If ODX make £1 per test and sell 46k tests per day to Mologic, it will take them 389 days to reach £17.9m of revenue.
If NCYT successfully scale up to 8m tests per month and sell them at a notional £5 per test (by all accounts it’s closer to £10) that is £40m revenue per month for NCYT, it would take ODX 869 days to reach this amount of revenue, so over 2 years.
So no PDMSPiper NCYT is not overvalued, it is in fact grossly undervalued in comparison to ODX based on the above conservative calculations.
Interested to read a constructive response as to what the flaws in this analysis are, as to me it seems clear cut from a financial perspective. If you could invest directly in Mologic then it would be a slightly different story.
Similarly with the rapid test consortium, ODX are the manufacturer of the test, not the developer, so will only receive a small portion of any sales revenue. All IMO of course, and please do you own research.