I think I am amongst the few to be on the verge of voting yes.11 May 2022 15:13
Not worth much but
In my opinion, what is on the table is the best deal they can get.
Voting no and hoping for a better monetary deal is not going to happen in my opinion, at best; better payment terms that do not stretch out for 15 years. Look at Kinross and see how their payment structure is set out.
AMC seem to be one of the few companies who are selling an asset in Russia during the conflict, therefore the payment plan which they have devised is their best guess at a plan that will be approved by the Russian Gov. The argument, 'to wait and see' what other company strategies other companies are taking is sound.
That being said
I believe Russia is changing the rules regularly to counter western sanctions set upon them, and no one is sure how far they will go, this is clearly evident with Order 81 which has recently been introduced also few other financial orgs warning of changes affecting business dealings in Russia. Therefore, for AMC to sit tight and wait (which I was advocating a few months back), where it looks like the war will continue for a long period of time, seems too risky now. They have a deal which if you believe in the FMV analysis seems fair, to mitigate the risk of losing it all. The uncertainty is the risk which rightly so the BOD have tried to mitigate that risk with the proposed offer.
Additionally
Some have commented on the RNS stating 'personal guarantee' I see this as a good thing, it also highlights the risk of the rules changing in Russia that may void the initial transaction.
The RNS clearly states the risk of financing the project if the deal is not done, Yes this is a normal statement to make, but the BOD has made it a clear statement in the RNS and we should take heed of that.
Regarding voting ‘no’ so that the BOD lose and gain nothing, just NO.
Whether it makes any difference,
In my 40s so have time left I hope, a young family, which I hope will have all the opportunities that my parents couldn’t afford to give me (but they gave me the most important thing and it was their time and attention), and be greater than what I have ever become.