RE: Cva question9 Nov 2022 19:16
Not meaning to stoke up fear but can the possibility of Joules using a CVA be compared to Debenhams?
In the run up to a CVA:
(from Sharecast news, February 12th 2019) “Shares in Debenhams surged 40% to 4.4p in the first half-hour of trading on Tuesday, having fallen around 95% over the past three years. Analyst John Stevenson at Peel Hunt said: "While this takes away the immediate pressure and provides a short respite, we believe Debenhams is likely to move forward with a CVA in order to reduce its lease commitments and store numbers, with longer-term financing also likely to be contingent on some form of equity raise."He added these prospect "may well secure the future of Debenhams...”
Shortly before the CVA were words of reassurance in an RNS: “Debenhams continues to make progress with its refinancing and restructuring discussions with existing lenders, Noteholders, and other stakeholders…”
and a Trading update on March 5th 2019 in which Sergio Bucher, Chief Executive of Debenhams, said: “We are making good progress with our stakeholder discussions to put the business on a firm footing for the future. We still expect that this process will lead to around 50 stores closing in the medium term.
"Our priority is to secure the best outcome for the business and all our stakeholders, whilst minimising the number of store closures and job losses. To do this, as we have said before, we will need the support of both landlords and local authorities to address our rents, rates and lease commitments. I would like to thank our staff - and all our stakeholders - for their continued support through this period, as we work to deliver a sustainable future for the company."”
THEN
Debenhams dropped it’s final piece of regulatory news on 9th April 2019: “Further to its announcement at 7.00 am this morning, Debenhams plc has requested that its shares be suspended with immediate effect, pending a further update.” (Share price at 2.04p and we know the rest!)
I don’t think shareholders will be wiped out in this case but I’m reevaluating the situation and have reduced my own holding to what I can afford to lose. With Joules talking about using a CVA, I believe the risk of worse case scenario for shareholders cannot be ignored.