Is this a Berkshire Hathaway type share or...29 Mar 2022 13:21
Warren Buffett once said, “The first rule of an investment is don't lose [money]. And the second rule of an investment is don't forget the first rule."
Furthermore Warren Buffett's strategy for picking winning stocks starts with evaluating a company based on his value investing philosophy.
Buffett looks for companies that provide a good return on equity over many years, particularly when compared to rival companies in the same industry.
When looking for a great company to invest in, Buffett also reviews a company's profit margins to ensure they are healthy and growing.
Buffett focuses on companies that provide a unique product or service that gives them a competitive advantage; he also focuses on companies that are undervalued that he can purchase at a good discount.
So how does HZM stand up?
Defensive value is solid, underpinned by cash and assets. You're not going to lose your money.
What about ROCE over many years? Using IRR as a good proxy indicator then with nickel at any value above $15k IRR will be above 25%, above $20k its well above 30% beating Buffet's target of 20% in all but calamity markets. Mine life is anything from 30-40 years, more than long enough.
Unique product or service? Nothing unique about nickel per se, but it is in constrained supply for the next decade or so, becoming more constrained by the day in fact. There isn't a substitute for it in stainless steel, and no obvious substitute for stainless in many applications. As a battery cathode other options may emerge in the future, but there is a lot of momentum behind Li Ion batteries right now. A ten year market rate offtake with Glencore also makes marketing pretty simple.
Competitive advantage - lowest quartile cost producer with amongst the highest ESG credentials in a Western friendly jurisdiction ticks that box I think.
So, you can chase around the market, winning and losing, or invest here Berkshire Hathaway style and wait for your profit to come to you. The first wait is for production, equity value growth of 3x or more in that time. The second wait is for scale up across the assets whilst generating income. Equity value growth a further 3x plus. The final wait would be for your dividends and income each year, with a huge projected IRR the dividend income could be higher than the current share price.