RE: Why is the sp here?30 Sep 2022 19:29
This is the difference between fundamentals and sentiment. While there have been delays, the plan has been very simple and has progressed as expected, minus the occasional improvement that wasn't foreseen such as buying the equipment ourselves. Even the catastrophic flooding was remedied quickly and without much incident. Regardless of the SP, we are currently profitable, but will expand that profitability with the 2nd HWM and ramping up production. This isn't a junior miner story where they "think" and "are very confident" and "expect" about factors such as hitting high grade ore. There is no guesswork here. As with everything there is some exposure to outside factors but I regard them all as pretty low risk - things like the met coal price suddenly tanking 50%.
The plan, repeated several times by Wilson, is to pay the 10p divi to fully pay back the IPO funders. BEN is owned 78% by insiders / institutional investors. The incentives are aligned. My expectation is that even if it doesn't happen on time it isn't going to be shelved as a concept, and that if it hasn't happened by end of Q1 2023 it will be considered a missed goal. From what has been said it sounds like THE goal of the company, the point at which they have really made it a success. Wilson was hoping that it would be able to be announced for the 1 year anniversary of the IPO, but delays have pushed the timeline back.
The sentiment here may be on a downtrend among traders because the company isn't full of surprises and promises with which to speculate on "value inflection points", they are just getting on with it in a steady manner. Long term investors also don't have the full picture at first glance - if you have a look at simplywallst, stockopedia or other investment advising sites, the FY21 results show it as a loss-making, young company. They don't have good data on the company, and so investment isn't coming in from those sources to displace traders. Even though this is a pre-divi stock, the management have been clear their aim is dividends in the near term and not some 10 year growth trajectory to becoming the met coal king of the US. Ultimately it comes down to trust they will continue with their stated plan, but strong incentive alignment significantly backs that up, and that is what BEN has in spades.