RE: Settlement Value13 Jan 2023 23:41
WishingAndHoping, I don't think you need to discount by 75%. Far from it. It depends what you are discounting by. Even if you were using inflation to discount which isn't reasonable under most models for discounting, and even with the most conservative assumption of 10% inflation to discount over every coming year for time horizon of the patents to 2028 or 2035... and even with a conservative assumption of Samsung's sales doubling every year over those projection periods, the discounts would be as follows:
Scenario A - patents run to 2028 with doubling sales for Samsung at 10% discount: apply 65%, ie reduce by 35%
Scenario B - patents run to 2035 with doubling sales for Samsung at 10% discount: apply 37%, ie reduce by 63% (but with more sales under this scenario due to the patents running for an extra 7 years).
And you could only apply such large discounts if Samsung were to acknowledged such large growth levels as the doubling every year, which would would mean significantly more royalties.
No expert would make such high assumptions of discount. Even our (incredible) central banks would not assume inflation would remain high this long. Even a prudent level of 5% inflation gives discount between 80% and 60% (ie reduce by 20% to 40%) over these periods, under the above assumptions.