RE: CINE - Should I buy or should I wait15 Jul 2021 22:26
BigPlan - thank you for your analysis. Here are my comments:
I personally never see movie studios disintermediating and leaving cinemas in the dust. For movie studios, streaming services are not that profitable for them. You stated in your analysis the stark difference between the cost to the consumer. Going to the cinema is a special experience for some, and as long as people are going into the cinema, the cinema will be the biggest profit maker for these movie studios. Movie studios get the bulk cost of the ticket that is sold to consumers, only a small amount goes to cineworld itself. Hence why concessionary products like popcorn and drinks are priced at a high mark up, so they can make their profit. The ads at the beginning also generate a good amount of money for the cinemas. So all in all, there are many ways that the cinema is profitable also.
In terms of rights issuing, many people have stated that a rights issue makes little sense at this current time for the scenario you are proposing. I think it’s safe to assume that CINE doesn’t need a rights issue immediately, and as you stated, the reason why they may need it is to improve the balance sheet. You’re correct there, but why would you do a rights issue when the stock is so low, when you could allow the stock to recover and then get more money from your rights issue. If they allow the stock to rise to circa 114p, they will get double the amount of money from the rights issue than if they did it now. (It doesn’t have to be at 114p specifically, but the point I’m trying to make is that CINE is missing out on a lot of additional money if they do the rights issue now).
Lastly, someone pointed out the remuneration and how that’s linked to the rights issue. From the report, we see that remuneration is contingent upon how how the stock price performs. To do a rights issue, and consequently dilute the stock, would mean that the prices needed for remuneration likely wouldn’t be met. We know that it’s unlikely that the company needs a rights issue right now, so why did the company make their remuneration report based on such prices, if they knew that a rights issue would be necessary in the future? It doesn’t really make sense, unless if I’m missing something.