RE: Huge upside MNH manganese mine6 Dec 2019 22:38
Ok BP-
I don't need to discount value of plant to zero as we have a RNS detailing at 30 June 2019 Total Assets were $1.6M, all I have said is that any claim for us to have $2M from this deal is utter ****** and it is
1: We are a shareholder so all we will benefit from is what MNH have available to pay as a dividend. Y?E 2018 $20K profit, YE 2019 OPERATIONS ie Gross Profit $1.4M Net profit will be way way below this, say being generous $0.35M less tax say $200K, dividends on those sort of numbers will be zero or negligible as you need to retain funds to invest in the business
2: Seriously how much working kit do you think there is? Supposedly they're going to be drilling more Manganese, opening RHA, drilling Zulu and Katete and shipping it all 1,500KM through customs in two African countries. I've done business there before. Yes there may be some complimentary skills but on the scale being bandied about extremely unlikely
3: Circum value is just twitter value, value is what somebody is prepared to pay and as far as I know we were the last mugs to pay a value.
4: Listen to podcast, its all govt have acknowledged (same way they acknowledged it was US $) not real hard cash coming
5: Zulu we are at the bottom of all resource classifications, it means diddly squat till a full Jorc compliant report
6: See 5, lowest form of classification, its a guesstimate nowhere near proven (about $5M away from being proven)
7: See 5 and 6, we've been told it's enormous but its not actually been drill at all
8: Dattels isn't invested, a company he is involved in has made a loan
9: This one I don't know you'd have to ask him and see what the salary is
10: See earlier $20K net profit YE 2018, YE 2019 profit unknown but we know they needed a $1M off Prem, hardly suggests making huge profits and a cash cow really does it?
11: Err you're missing the point we won't be buying more MNH it'll be a coming together and then a dilution to raise the cash at which point GR and BR will convert their loans into the new already diluted company IMO
Not a crusade against Prem at all, you made 11 points, 9 of them don't really stack up against the facts, 1 I don't know and 11 my opinion is different to yours