RE: Interview Stockbox2 Jun 2023 21:37
Re the timing of the judgment, a few points from the perspective of a barrister:
- the timing of a reserved judgment depends on how long it takes the judge to write it
- sometimes judges give an indication of how long they think it will take, but usually they don’t
- if they don’t, nobody else has any real idea: the legal team may say they would expect it to be about x but they’re basically guessing
- even if the judge does give an indication, it’s usually unreliable: it’s hard for the judge to estimate (a) how many hours it will take to write the judgment, and (b) what other commitments he or she will have over the relevant period
- in this case, the judge’s concluding remarks at the end of the hearing were reported in the press and I don’t recall seeing an estimated timescale
- accordingly, if JW has given an estimated timescale before, he was probably passing on what his own lawyers estimated, but they in turn will have been basically guessing
- sometimes, a judge’s clerk will update the parties on progress during the judgment-writing process: perhaps the new estimate of September comes from the judge’s clerk, but there’s no way of us knowing that
- unless the NI High Court works differently to the London one, September is part of the summer vacation, meaning that it’s more likely to be either July or October (that being so, one might hope for a push for July)
- TLDR it’ll be done when the judge gets it done