RE: Cosmens24 Nov 2025 09:56
The performance of ALSA and the mid to long term opportunity for the company are not in dispute. Would be hard to argue that. Also, it really is not necessarily shorting creating this dip. Without a meaningful update they are in a precarious position with no auditors, a questionable net asset position and a contract which actually cannot be defined in terms of profitability/liability. Retail shorts and those that have bought a seat might try their luck.
In building the business they simply stacked up intangibles and this is a great example of why when you acquire a company you strip the intangibles apart. Most of them should simply not be on the balance sheet as they are irrelevant to the true worth of a company. They are just a horrible accounting reality! They are non-cash related but impact the net asset value of the company. This was already down to a couple of hundred million. Not sure what the net of the NSAB was (cash in - intangible and working asset write off). Maybe there is another hit to net assets there.
Germany seems already well covered by the future contract provision in place ... a positive resolution there could reverse some of that. There's actually potential for a huge upside which if coincides with UK mess getting sorted, would propel the SP back to the 70/80p type level.
Now should net assets for any reason go negative. It's not a disaster. Short term, any covenants around net assets could be waived but some funds might have issues remaining invested and that's probably the bigger issue and a pressure point for any potential capital restructure which would be resisted and the Cosmens alone have nigh on enough to block that out. So it could well be that some are switching to a CFD equivelant product.
It's just a situation which is completely unrelated to the companies ability to pay it's bills and purely short term.
What I expect is that even worst case scenario, their own cash generation (which from memory runs as 90+%) should keep them in positive net asset territory. All just my opinion and guesswork though. I'm holding and will wait for the update ... I think this Phil White knows well the game he's playing and how to fix things.