Songwe Basket Case (Rough Calcs)11 Jul 2025 09:56
Seems like one of the final arguments is Songwe is not economic, I need to conduct a thorough investigation now with NdPr set at $110KG (which is absolutely incredible!)
So the initial DFS stated a post tax NPV of $559m (10% discount)
IRR was 31% for for the interests of national security, lets put that aside for now. (US invested over $260m in Lynas and clearly just invested in MP, and payback wasnt an issue compared to supply)
Production was estimated at 6000 tonnes per annum give or take, 55% TREO and about 31% of the basket was NDPR - THIS IS CRUCIAL.
Years 1-5 were estimated to be less whilst we ramp up, so lets just say 4000 tpa for years 1-5
Initial capex was around $300m with contingency payments.
Nd Pr Ty DB contribute basically 90% of the value of the basket, NOW AS POINTED OUT, when the DFS was done NDPR was trading at around $130-150KG
Costs were estimated at around $15-21KG, as many have mentioned here (even those with concerns)
At $110KG NDPR, the total basket case IF I HAVE WORKED IT OUT PROPERLY stands at around $29KG give or take.
The costs should remain controlled as it is open pit mining. And industry costs are coming down or stabilising.
So if we calculate the NDPR contribution which is 31% of the 55% TREO in MREC, then we end up with 0.17 x 110 = around $19KG give or take just for the NdPR
The DFS had us at around $32KG, so lets take off the $19KG for the floor NdPR pricing
Dy and TB are still pretty hot products, but to be even safer, we will drop the rest of the MREC pricing by 60%.
Even with the rest of the MREC discounted by 60%, we still get to around $23KG production.
With costs at $15-21KG, if they come in at the top end then margins will be tight, but profiable and enough for a similar proposal to MP (where when prices flip, the US and the company get upside)
So best profits $8KG, worst case around $2KG
However many are forgetting PULAWAY
This was presented to enhance the Songwe economics, by stated 33%.
So if we add Pulawy into the SPAC (which we have) we can seriously reduce those costs, giving the mine another outlet to be highly profitable.
This assumes no price floors for other materials (like Dy and TB)