RE: Revenue recognition - note 54 Apr 2023 16:35
Rampmaster
"AFC Energy is working with its auditors to confirm the appropriate accounting and disclosures for the revised agreement within the accounts."
"So as with everything in the accounts, including 'note 5', this is all done WITH the auditor's advice and sign-off"
Your interpretation of the above indicates how little you know. Do you actually know what an auditor's role is, and how the company interacts with the auditor? I guess not. It is the company's responsibility to prepare the accounts in accordance with GAAP, and present these to the auditor. They then undertake the necessary verification work to ensure that the accounts presented reconcile to the base records,. and that all entries accord with the correct accounting treatment, as set out in the various reporting standards (FRS). The auditor's job is NOT to advise the company, they are an independent review function, and are by definition, reactive, it is because of this impartiality that large firms have different ring fences departments to deal with accounts and tax advisory and audit. If there were an area that the company was unsure about, it would have sought advice from the reporting accountant, and NOT the auditor, and the matter would (or, more importantly SHOULD) have been resolved before the accounts got anywhere near an audit. Your supposition that auditors are advisory is simply plain wrong.
The more likely scenario is that the accounts were prepared and presented to the auditors, who then had concerns over revenue recognition, namely whether the company could realistically regard the £2.0M as current income, or deferred income (the treatment is dependent on the contractual obligations, which we as mere investors simply don't know). In any case, it doesn't look good for the FD to have his considered view on the treatment of items in the accounts which HE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR to be given consideration by the auditors.... if he doesn't know how things should be treated in his own company's accounts then what hope is there?
I think we can all guess what the salient points requiring consideration are.....