Buyback - Will it have a real effect ?27 Oct 2021 13:38
Hi all.
Just wondered if shareholders are going to agree to the buyback ?
https://www.investopedia.com/articles/stocks/10/share-buybacks.asp
Buybacks are trendy at the moment but split opinion. I've experienced three buybacks from a holders perspective.
TSG, Trans-Siberian Gold. Their buyback more than doubled the share price. There were very few shares in liquidity, most holders were large institutions and held through.
DLG Direct Line's buyback is so small with such a small effect it's hardly worth doing.
BP, IMO is a self serving way the BOD grease themselves with issuing shares and then buying them and canceling them, benefit to holders is minimal despite them spending over 25 billion on buybacks since the naughties.
PAF's monthly volume averages around 50m since 2020, so that may mean around 25m shares sold which PAF could buy and cancel. Meaning around $6m spend a month at 18p would take around 100m shares off the market in 4 months for $24m.
A 5% reduction in shares and around 5% increase in share price.
Alternatively, for $24m we could get another dividend of 0.9p, or a large funding help for Mintails etc.
Personally, I'd rather the dividend if this is the kind of level, so such a buyback I'd vote against.
If they're just going to spend a few million dollars, then it really will not make much of a difference except the buzzword "Buyback" could attract shareholders, so I would approve of that.
Any thoughts ?