EGM6 Feb 2020 12:31
Vote FOR the proposal imo.
Saloro’s debt pile is already huge, and significantly more funds are needed following the latest debacle with the old (actually quite recent) mine workings. In reality the amount required going forward even in the short term can’t be stated with any confidence, because major unforeseen issues keep arising, and it’s become clear that the technical, DD and risk management work has fallen well short. As shareholders, we’ve never seen the JV or loan documents, but even if you don’t believe the ORM bod, it’s a safe bet that as things stand Saloro are near default anyway, with limited progress and product sales unlikely to be anywhere near covering loan and repayment covenants.
Much better to bale out now, and at least recover E6m, rather than risk continuing involvement and further funding requirements, or risk security enforcement and lose everything.
ORM’s interest in Barruecopardo is unlikely to be readily marketable, saleable or fundable in the open market atm. Probably the only realistic buyer is Oaktree itself (who else?), and there’s a negotiated sale to them on the table already. And the only realistic lender to Saloro is…er… also Oaktree (again who else?), charging ridiculous rates. Despite looking, no other lender was found for the most recent loan, for example. So it’s also far too great a risk to think we can somehow sell elsewhere, or force Oaktree’s hand into switching from an interest in asset sale/purchase, to eg an offer for ORM the company, by voting down the negotiated sale proposal. Oaktree could just wait for the inevitable default, and step in or enforce security and wipe us out. ORM are in a parlous position with little influence.
It’s better to have any shareholders revolt from a position of relative strength, ie once we’ve got the E6m in the coffers, rather than from the current weak position where we’re risking everything. But let’s see what the new BoD looks like before picking up the pitchforks. Imo.
Broomfielder, you’re spot on with your comments on SP, NAV, and RTO potential.