RE: RNS6 Jan 2023 16:05
TheTrotsky, I feel more optimistic about this.
MSG buys Topps, you ask for what? But then go on to say that Earnings are increasing, and the company is on a good footing. Why would you not take this private? You dont have to change the structure much, you could keep it running as it is, but buy 30% stock from Cersanit - which is what they are asking for. This would give you options to penetrate the UK market as it evolves (high end / low end), and even dictate terms to other suppliers. I dont see any of this as a problem or negative outcome for Solowow. The valuation of Topps is historically low, and many UK equities are targets for overseas buyers. You seem to be looking at it, like it would get bought then ripped apart and then broken, when I say just a change of ownership and adjustment of supply chain. I think for Solowow, this offers upside to both investments. He must understand the tiles businesses well. At present the only issue Topps have with the proposal is that it is not in the interests of shareholders and doesn't quite fit their business model. Both of these are the benefits for the buyer.
Regarding the cost, if you have the money, and you think there will be a return, whats the issue with paying around 80p for the other 70%. Having checked my analyses platform the median broker consensus (of 2) is 80p. The highest is £1.00 target for 12 months. The guy has 6 billion. What else can he do with that money. His hobby seems to be buying building materials firms. Im sure its worth more to him than most other people. Maybe it enables further expansion in the low end market - possibly even accross Europe. Looking at his purchases, he has waited for valuations to come down (not bought since 2018). I really think he will have a go at this.
Apologies if I'm over simplifying things, I am not a M&A expert, or usually an investor of retailers. The deciding factor was the person, Solowow I think hes a smart cookie. I see minimal downside risk to test my thesis, and have only bought a few thousand shares. First time I have bought due to analysing that a TO or even speculation of one may occur. Happy to own Topps at 47p currently and enjoy the show.
I think the talk of being a UK competitor is just posturing, possibly to reduce speculation of a TO at this point.